Enter your keyword

Judicial Transfers

Judicial Transfers

Judicial Transfers

Judicial Transfers: How the Absence of Policy Produces Unintended Gender Inequality

A judge seeking a transfer should not have to win a public argument about the value of her family responsibilities. Yet that is what transfer interviews increasingly demand. At the Judicial Service Commission’s (JSC) October 2026 interviews, two North West High Court judges, Sandiswa Mfenyana and Frances Reid, requested to transfer to the Gauteng Division to be closer to family members who needed their care. Both were probed and made to defend the most private details of their lives in public. The fault with that line of questioning lies less with the commissioners who asked the questions than with the absence of a policy to guide them on what to ask.

A judge seeking a transfer should not have to win a public argument about the value of her family responsibilities. Yet that is what transfer interviews increasingly demand.

Procedure without policy

High Court judges are appointed to a specific division. Moving permanently to another is not an administrative reassignment: the judge must wait for a vacancy to be advertised, apply, be shortlisted and be interviewed alongside other candidates, as if seeking appointment afresh. The only exception is a presidential transfer under section 50(5) of the Superior Courts Act, which allows the President to authorise transfers without the JSC to promote effective court administration in certain divisions, such as Limpopo, Mpumalanga and North West. While it is couched as a transfer, that section has been used only to second judges from other provinces to establish new High Courts in Mpumalanga and Limpopo.

Since a sitting judge’s competence is already established, a transfer interview turns largely on one question: why does the judge want to move? Yet nothing tells commissioners, or candidates, what counts as a good reason.

Since a sitting judge’s competence is already established, a transfer interview turns largely on one question: why does the judge want to move? Yet nothing tells commissioners, or candidates, what counts as a good reason. The JSC’s “Consolidated Criteria, Guidelines and Procedure” refers to transfers in three short paragraphs (paras 70-72). A transfer may be considered only once a vacancy is advertised; the judge must complete the standard questionnaire and be interviewed with other candidates; and the move may be effected only on the JSC’s recommendation. This is a process, not a policy. It says how a judge may apply, but nothing about the grounds on which a transfer should be granted.

Lessons from the lower courts

The lower courts show what a policy could look like. Regulation 22 of the regulations made under the Magistrates Act mirrors the JSC’s draft procedure almost exactly. The difference is that the Magistrates Commission goes further and spells out the grounds on which a transfer will be considered. These include frequent recusals caused by long service at a small station, a life-threatening illness of the magistrate or an immediate family member (supported by specialist reports), and a security threat confirmed by SAPS. Candidates set out their reasons in writing beforehand, and the interviews are closed. Magistrates, in other words, know what they must show, how to prove it, and that their private lives will stay private. Judges have none of these assurances.

Magistrates, in other words, know what they must show, how to prove it, and that their private lives will stay private. Judges have none of these assurances.

Five interviews, five different tests

Without a shared standard, each transfer interview becomes its own test, as five recent cases show.

Judge Nozuko Mjali

In October 2014, four years after her appointment, Judge Nozuko Mjali asked to move from the Mthatha seat of the Eastern Cape Division to Bhisho, 230 km away. Her husband had been arrested on rape charges at home in front of their three children, one of whom has special needs, and the children were left traumatised and unsupervised after school. Rather than engage with that, commissioners pressed her to justify moving to a more urban seat and asked why she had not simply sent her children to boarding school. In tears, she said she was there for “any mother who finds herself in this situation”. The transfer was refused, and the vacancy went unfilled that year.

Judge Gloria Nozuko Mjali Judges Matter

Judge Gloria Nozuko Mjali


Judge Bulelwa Pakati Judges Matter

Judge Bulelwa Pakati

Judge Bulelwa Pakati

Five years later, a different panel took a very different approach. Judge Pakati, born in the Eastern Cape and serving there as a magistrate for many years, was appointed to the Kimberley High Court in 2012. In 2019, she sought a transfer home to Gqeberha, telling the JSC she had been diagnosed with depression, which she attributed to judicial politics in Kimberley, and that her family relied on her income. Her interview lasted eight minutes, and the transfer was granted.

Judge Thina Siwendu

The pattern of easy approval continued in October 2025, when Judge Thina Siwendu, a Gauteng judge since 2017, sought a transfer to KwaZulu-Natal to return home and be near the surgeons who had operated on her. Her 35-minute interview was collegial throughout. That may be because leaving the country’s busiest division for a quieter one raises no suspicion of opportunism. However, without a stated test, there is no way to know.

Judge Thina Siwendu Judges Matter

Judge Thina Siwendu


Judges Sandiswa (Mickey) Mfenyana Judges Matter

Judges Sandiswa (Mickey) Mfenyana

Judges Sandiswa (Mickey) Mfenyana and Frances Reid

A year later, Judges Mfenyana and Reid met a far less accommodating panel. Judge Mfenyana, appointed to the North West High Court in 2023, has been acting in Gauteng since November 2024 and sought a permanent move to care for her mother, who has an irreversible illness. Her interview ran to an hour and ten minutes and was considerably less smooth than Judge Siwendu’s.

Judge Frances Reid was appointed to the North West High Court in Mahikeng in 2021 and has been acting in Pretoria since 2025. After the deaths of her father and brother-in-law, she became the sole breadwinner for her mother, sister and niece, with her mother and niece needing specialised care that is not available in Mahikeng. Reid has herself been diagnosed with depression and submitted a psychiatrist’s note stating that being near her family helps her work better. Her interview lasted just over an hour.

…transfers are almost unheard of unless there are good and rational grounds, and that the prevailing position is that transfers should not be accommodated.

Both candidates were grilled on administrative and institutional questions regarding transfers. They were both asked about the impact on racial and gender transformation should their transfers be granted; the strain on the division from losing two judges at once; and the cost to the North West budget of appointing two acting judges while the incumbents serve in Gauteng. They were told that transfers are almost unheard of unless there are good and rational grounds, and that the prevailing position is that transfers should not be accommodated. Furthermore, they were reminded that, at every interview, a judge commits to remaining in the particular division to which they are appointed. Judge Reid was bizarrely asked who, between herself and Judge Mfenyana, had more compelling reasons to transfer.

Judge Mfenyana was told that transfers are a burden on the JSC and was asked what considerations should be taken into account when assessing reasons for transfers. Close to tears, Mfenyana observed that without guidelines, the process is open to abuse.

The issues raised with both candidates are fair concerns. The problem, however, is how they were raised, and on whom the burden was placed. The claim that transfers should not be accommodated sits uneasily with the JSC’s own draft rules and past practice, which expressly provide for them.

Why this matters: the unintended gender impact

The strain caused by these interviews may not be deliberate, but the impact on women is hard to ignore. Every judge discussed here is a woman. Every judge who has sought to move because of their own or a relative’s illness, or because of family care responsibilities, is also a woman. That is not a coincidence. Women carry a disproportionate share of unpaid care for children, ageing parents and sick relatives. A transfer process that turns on personal circumstances, assessed without criteria and in public, falls hardest on women judges.

It does so in four ways:

  • First, it makes public disclosure of illness, trauma and family crises the price of being heard. Deputy Minister of Justice Andries Nel acknowledged this during Judge Mfenyana’s interview, saying his heart went out to a judge made to engage in “intensely private matters” in “a very public forum”.
  • Second, it lets outcomes turn on individual commissioners’ views of what a mother or daughter ought to do: send the children to boarding school or move an ill parent to another province.
  • Third, it turns judicial transformation against the women it has recruited to diversify the judiciary. Women whose appointments improved a division’s demographics become obliged to stay, whatever their circumstances, to protect those numbers, while the responsibility for transformation shifts from the JSC to the individual judge. It also weakens the substance of transformation: what use is changing the demographics if the judiciary’s institutional cultures, policies and practices are hostile to diversity?
  • Fourth, by inviting candidates to rank their hardship against one another, it pits women against women.

Inconsistency compounds the harm. Judge Pakati was granted a transfer after eight minutes; Judge Mjali was refused after a gruelling interview. Without stated criteria, the public cannot tell whether such differences reflect principle, the strength of the evidence, the needs of the divisions, or simply the panel’s composition on the day. As Deputy Minister Nel warned, without a policy, the JSC risks being seen as biased or preferential whenever it

Without stated criteria, the public cannot tell whether such differences reflect principle, the strength of the evidence, the needs of the divisions, or simply the panel’s composition on the day.

What a policy should do

None of this means transfers should be easy. Concerns about divisional capacity, cost and forum-shopping are real, but they should be weighed against published criteria rather than improvised in each interview. Following the Magistrates Commission, the JSC should recognise clear grounds for transfer, such as serious illness of the judge or a close relative, caregiving responsibilities, and security threats.

Medical and similar evidence should be submitted in writing and considered confidentially, leaving public questioning to focus on the grounds rather than the details. The Judge Presidents of both divisions involved in the transfer should report to the JSC on capacity and need, and a minimum service period should be required, with exceptions for compelling cases. This would address the concern that judges use one division as a stepping stone to another. Above all, the policy should make clear that transformation is the JSC’s collective responsibility, not a burden on individual women seeking transfers.

Above all, the policy should make clear that transformation is the JSC’s collective responsibility, not a burden on individual women seeking transfers.

As Deputy Minister Nel observed, the move towards a single judiciary presents an opportunity to establish such a framework. But the JSC need not wait for broader institutional reform. It is already revising its procedures, and judicial transfers are an obvious place to begin. Until clear criteria are adopted, judges, most visibly women judges, will continue to have their family circumstances assessed according to an unwritten standard that shifts from one sitting to the next, doing harm to those women and to the judiciary.

Dimakatso Nchodu is a Research and Advocacy Officer at Judges Matter, a transparency project of the Democratic Governance and Rights Unit at the University of Cape Town that monitors the South African judiciary.

No Comments

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.